Shift Leader

Company: Insomnia Cookies
Location: Old Town
Posted on: February 16, 2026

Job Description:

Job Description Job Description As a Shift Leader at our Westown MKE store located at 1133 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee WI 53203 , you are the captain of our bakery day or night! You understand what it takes to “Own the Night” (and beyond), by predicting the flow of business during a successful shift. Your hands-on leadership style should not only include building orders, suggestive selling, baking, and interacting with customers – it will also mean taking pride in knowing that your prowess as a leading Insomniac attributes to a productive and fun night for your store! SOME OUR SWEET SHIFT LEADER PERKS: • Flexible part-time work schedules • Excellent training & mentorship • Pet insurance for your furry loved ones • Job stability with a rapidly growing and reputable company • Achievable growth/promotion opportunities • You get to work in a fun, exciting team environment • FREE cookies with every shift! WHAT WILL I DO AS A SHIFT LEADER? • Provide incredible customer service and quality products to all of our guests throughout their experience within our bakeries • Support store leadership by maintaining operations during your shift, communicating pertinent information, monitoring production efficiency, holding the team accountable to company standards and procedures, and assisting in the training and coaching of team members • Prioritize and delegate tasks for baking, cashiering, packaging, and cleaning while leading the cookie crew team • Support and work alongside the Cookie Crew • Provide a safe, clean, working environment for our guests and staff and adhere to safe food handling practices • Manage cash handling and deposits DESIRED SKILLS/EXPERIENCE: • At least 1 year of working experience in a customer service focused role • Point of Sales systems experience • Outstanding communication, time management, and people skills • Outgoing/friendly/patient • Detail focused and results-oriented • Ability to lead-by-example and motivate others • Ability to lift up to 40 lbs. • Legally eligible to work in the United States • Must be 18 years or older to be employed About us: Insomnia Cookies was founded in a college dorm room by then-student, Seth Berkowitz. Fast forward 20 years and so manycookies later, our innovative bakery delivery concept has become a cult brand known for its rabid following of cookie lovers who crave Insomnia’s warm, delicious delivery all day and late into the night. With an expanding footprint of over 300 stores globally, an experiential, “sweet-easy” concept as the brand’s flagship in Philadelphia, Pa. (where Insomnia Cookies is headquartered), and a rapidly-growing nationwide shipping and gifting portfolio Insomnia Cookies is revolutionizing the cookie game by truly " Imagining What’s Possible "!

Keywords: Insomnia Cookies, New England , Shift Leader, Hospitality & Tourism , Old Town, Northeast